Six European Union member states, including Poland, have urged the European Commission (EC) to take decisive action against Chinese e-commerce platforms Shein and Temu, claiming the companies are delivering goods to EU customers that fail to meet European standards. The appeal comes amid growing concerns over the safety, legality, and consumer protection standards regarding products sold through these platforms.
In a letter to the EC, Germany, backed by Poland, France, the Netherlands, Austria, and Denmark, expressed frustration over the unchecked flow of goods into Europe that allegedly do not comply with EU regulations. The joint appeal was made public on Thursday, ahead of a meeting of EU ministers responsible for competition policy.
Push for Fair Competition and Consumer Protection
The six EU nations are particularly concerned about the competitive advantage these platforms gain by ignoring EU rules. The letter stresses that strict enforcement of existing regulations is necessary to maintain fair competition and protect consumers from potentially harmful products.
“If violations of the law are not rigorously detected and punished, it will harm consumers and create an unfair playing field for law-abiding suppliers,” the letter warns. The signatories emphasize the need for manufacturers and e-commerce platforms, including those from outside the EU, to adhere to the EU’s strict standards. This would ensure fair competition within the internal market and provide consumers with safe and compliant products.
The letter specifically mentions Temu and Shein, which the European Commission had previously classified as “very large online platforms.” This designation obligates the companies to comply with the Digital Services Act (DSA), a recently introduced EU law aimed at regulating the online sale of illegal products and services. The DSA also targets the spread of harmful content on digital platforms, placing a significant burden of responsibility on larger entities like Temu and Shein.
Concerns Over Product Safety and Counterfeit Goods
One of the primary concerns raised in the letter relates to the sale of counterfeit goods and products lacking proper safety certifications. Consumer advocacy groups in Europe have previously raised alarms about the nature of goods available on these platforms, with claims ranging from unsafe electronics to clothing containing harmful substances. Additionally, there are accusations of deceptive practices, such as directing consumers towards more expensive items.
The rise of online shopping, accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, has resulted in platforms like Temu and Shein growing in popularity across Europe. However, this rapid growth has been accompanied by regulatory challenges. Many European businesses argue that the platforms enjoy an unfair advantage by bypassing rules that local companies must follow, including product safety standards, customs duties, and VAT regulations.
Call for Stricter Enforcement of the Digital Services Act
In their appeal, the six EU countries have called on the European Commission to collect more detailed data from national digital service coordinators about violations committed by platforms like Temu and Shein. They suggest that these platforms be held to the standards set out in the Digital Services Act and that additional enforcement mechanisms be implemented.
One proposed measure is the introduction of a “digital product passport,” which would require every product sold online to come with a comprehensive digital specification, ensuring it meets EU regulations. This digital passport could help authorities track the origin and compliance of products more efficiently.
The Digital Services Act (DSA) already requires large platforms to monitor the legality of the goods and services they offer. However, the six countries argue that without proper enforcement, the law will have little effect in curbing the sale of non-compliant goods.
Growing Scrutiny of Temu and Shein in Europe
Public concern regarding Temu and Shein’s operations in Europe has grown in recent years, with numerous complaints filed by consumer organizations. In addition to product safety, these groups have also raised issues related to intellectual property, claiming that the platforms sell counterfeit goods and violate copyright laws. These allegations have sparked calls for more stringent scrutiny of the platforms’ supply chains and better protections for European businesses.
In Poland, the Ministry of Development and Technology has previously voiced concerns about Temu, citing similar issues. The ministry, along with other EU counterparts, is now pressing the European Commission to ensure that these platforms are held accountable.
The Road Ahead
As the popularity of Chinese e-commerce platforms like Temu and Shein continues to grow in Europe, regulators are increasingly concerned about the impact on local markets, consumers, and businesses. The joint letter from the six EU countries marks a significant step towards ensuring that these platforms adhere to European regulations.
The European Commission now faces the challenge of balancing the promotion of free trade with the need to protect consumers and local industries from unfair competition. The introduction of stricter enforcement measures, such as the proposed digital product passport, could help bring greater transparency to online marketplaces. However, it remains to be seen how effectively these platforms will be monitored and whether they will comply with the rigorous demands of EU law.
As the debate intensifies, the spotlight remains firmly on the European Commission to take action and uphold the standards that protect consumers and ensure a level playing field for businesses across the EU.
